News

Employee Benefits Are Personal

Written by Kirsti Karpawich | Aug 14, 2026, 2:36:24 PM

Employee benefits can sit in an uncomfortable place for organizations.

They are deeply personal for employees and their families, but they also represent a major financial commitment for the organization. For many employers, benefits are often one of the largest expenses after payroll so the decisions tied to them can affect budgets, retention, recruitment, and the overall culture of the organization.

I have worked in employee benefits for roughly 25 years, and the longer I do this work, the more I believe employers need more than a broker. They need an advisor who understands the business, the people inside it, and the pressure leaders feel when the numbers get difficult.

Employers Need More Than a Renewal Conversation

A strong benefits strategy cannot be built around a single renewal meeting. By the time renewal numbers are on the table, many employers are already working inside a narrow set of options.

The more valuable work starts earlier by understanding where the organization is today and where it is trying to go, and how benefits play into that path. For some employers, the immediate pressure may be cost. For others, the larger concern may be employee access, workforce stability, or the need to compete for talent in a difficult labor market.

In senior living, for example, leaders are often trying to support employees who are doing physically and emotionally demanding work while also managing tight margins and ongoing staffing pressure. Municipalities face their own set of expectations, including public accountability, budget constraints, and the need to make decisions that hold up over time.

But both types of organization need an advisor who can evaluate funding mechanisms, plan design, vendor performance, compliance considerations, and employee impact without turning every conversation into data analysis.

The recommendation has to be understandable. But it also has to be thoughtful, and it has to connect back to the employer’s goals.

Trust Is Built When Things Get Difficult

Trust is easy to talk about when the numbers are favorable, but it is truly tested when renewal increases are high, claims are unpredictable, or an employer is facing a difficult decision that will affect employees.

Those moments are never comfortable, but they are often the moments that define the relationship.

When a client is under pressure, they need steady guidance. They need transparency early enough to prepare, and they need a consultant who can explain what is happening, what options are available, and what trade-offs come with each path.

There may not always be a perfect solution. In fact, there rarely is a perfect solution. More often, many solutions involve balancing cost, access, and employee experience.

I often tell my team that the way we handle difficult situations speaks louder than anything we say in a positive renewal conversation. When we stay calm, direct, and methodical, clients can feel the difference. They know we are not disappearing when the work gets hard.

The Member Has to Stay in the Conversation

Benefits are financial, but they are never only financial.

Employers are spending real dollars, and they deserve to know those dollars are being managed responsibly. At the same time, every plan change eventually reaches an employee or family member trying to use the benefit.

For nonprofit employers and organizations with lower-wage employee populations, that balance becomes even more important. A plan may look efficient on paper, but if employees avoid care because everyday costs are too high, the strategy is not doing its job.

The goal is to help employers make the most of their benefits spend while keeping the employee experience firmly in view. Sometimes that means looking carefully at plan design. Sometimes it means evaluating alternative funding arrangements or taking a closer look at vendor relationships. Sometimes it means asking whether the current approach still fits the organization’s workforce.

At Borislow, we try to help employers see benefits as part of the culture of the organization, not just a line item to control. The financial discipline still has to be there, but the human impact has to stay visible.

Long-Term Relationships Make Better Strategy Possible

The majority of my client relationships have lasted one or two decades. Over that kind of time, you see organizations change. You see leadership teams evolve, employee populations shift, and financial priorities move in new directions.

But as those things happen, a benefits strategy should be able to grow with the organization.

A company that started with a small, professional workforce may eventually become a much larger operation with different needs. A senior living organization may face new staffing realities and a manufacturer may need to think further ahead about sustainability and member impact.

A consultative relationship creates room for those conversations before the pressure is urgent. It gives employers space to explore what may need to change over the next few years, rather than only reacting to the current renewal.

For me, that is part of what keeps the work interesting. Benefits require analytical thinking, but they also require creativity, communication, and constant learning. The industry keeps moving, and advisors have to keep moving with it.

Leadership Means Helping People Grow into Their Strengths

The same approach I value with clients also shapes how I lead internally.

I have always believed in understanding what people want from their careers and helping them find roles where they can succeed. Some people want to be client-facing while others prefer to work behind the scenes. Some are energized by difficult conversations, while others contribute best optimizing member engagement.

Good leadership requires paying attention to those differences.

I get a lot of energy from seeing people grow, stretch, and ultimately surpass my skill set in some areas. When people feel supported and appreciated, they usually work harder and bring better service to clients.

Mentorship also plays a major role in this industry. Employee benefits has a steep learning curve and it takes time to understand funding, compliance, plan design, carrier relationships, client communication, and the many moving parts that shape a recommendation.

For women building careers in benefits consulting, finding a strong mentor can make a tremendous difference. This industry rewards curiosity, resilience, empathy, and the ability to be direct when the situation calls for it. Women can bring a strong combination of care and discipline to this work, which is especially valuable when employers are trusting us with large budgets and decisions that affect their people.

The Future of Benefits Requires Better Guidance

Employers are navigating a system that can be expensive and difficult to understand. Many leaders do not enjoy working on benefits because the stakes are high and the answers are rarely simple.

A good advisor helps make the work more manageable. Not by oversimplifying it, but by bringing order to the conversation and keeping the employer’s goals, budget, and employees in view.

For senior living organizations, municipalities, nonprofits, manufacturers and other employers carrying significant benefits pressure, the right consulting relationship can change the way decisions are made.

The work is financial. The work is personal. The work is long-term.

And when it is done well, employers feel supported through the hard decisions, employees have benefits that better fit their needs, and the organization has a stronger foundation for what comes next.